MB

 

Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
BACK TO THE MANCHESTER BIRDING WEBSITE HOMEPAGE -> Manchester Birding Forum -> GENERAL BIRDING DISCUSSION -> McKerchars mystery birds
Post Info TOPIC: McKerchars mystery birds
Steve Suttill


Status: Offline
Posts: 1605
Date:
RE: McKerchars mystery birds
Permalink  

And I'd just made it a New Year's Resolution to enter every month this year - even the gulls smile

Seriously though, it has been fun and an education but even Ian needs a break now and then!



__________________
Steve "Make your birdwatching count!"
Ian Campbell


Status: Offline
Posts: 2660
Date:
Permalink  

Just to add my thanks publically like many others have, thanks a lot for providing a great competition.
Cheers Ian

__________________
Dennis atherton


Status: Offline
Posts: 819
Date:
Permalink  

A great bit of fun and knowledge is now lost. I really enjoyed the results and especially the ones when once you have the answer you start to kick yourself for not seeing what now seems obvious. Its a pity it's over with but there is only so much one man can do. Now Ian has only 300 things to concentrate on instead of 301smile cheers for the competition. It was grest while bit lasted smile

__________________
Did you see it? It was small and brown and flew that way.........................
Pete Kinsella


Status: Offline
Posts: 61
Date:
Permalink  

Many thanks Ian for running the Mystery Bird quiz , I`m sure everyone who took part appreciates all the hard work that went into it. Having even been distracted by the quiz whilst birding on the other side of the planet on more than one occasion , I`ll miss it.

__________________
Craig Higson


Status: Offline
Posts: 1274
Date:
Permalink  

Thanks for running it Ian. At least the last few strands of hair on my head are now safe biggrin

__________________
No one on their death bed ever said they wished they'd spent more time at work. http://bitsnbirds.blogspot.co.uk
Pete Welch


Status: Offline
Posts: 459
Date:
Permalink  

Whilst I wasn't too good on the IDs it nevertheless cheered me up whenever Ian chose any of my photos to challenge the experts - and a good way to excuse some terrible shots too :) Peter

__________________
Building my lifers
Nick Hilton


Status: Offline
Posts: 709
Date:
Permalink  

yes, a great disapointment that there will be no competition for 2014, heres hoping that there will be a resurrection in the future.

Congrats to Pete K for continued dominance in 2013.

__________________
Nev Wright


Status: Offline
Posts: 202
Date:
Permalink  

Yes thanks Ian, it was great!

__________________
Tony Darby


Status: Offline
Posts: 382
Date:
Permalink  

JOHN TYMON wrote:

Tim Wilcox wrote:

So it's all over and I got just over 50% as per usual but the Mystery Birds has been my favourite competition ever. Huge thanks to Ian for giving us all such a great challenge over the last few years. I'll miss it


#

Same here will miss it a lot cry

-- Edited by JOHN TYMON on Sunday 19th of January 2014 08:50:40 PM


Me too!!

__________________
dave broome


Status: Offline
Posts: 2872
Date:
Permalink  

Congratulations are due to Ian for consistently running this competition for seven years. How you found enough hours in the day will be the one unanswered mystery. With the competition's end (or break?) and the demise of Birding World both occurring this month, there's a bit of time freed up. Never missed entering it, despite all the Homer Simpson-esque utterances of 'doh!' as I realised mistakes upon reading the answers. Classic stuff.smile

__________________
JOHN TYMON


Status: Offline
Posts: 3599
Date:
Permalink  

Tim Wilcox wrote:

So it's all over and I got just over 50% as per usual but the Mystery Birds has been my favourite competition ever. Huge thanks to Ian for giving us all such a great challenge over the last few years. I'll miss it


#

Same here will miss it a lot cry

-- Edited by JOHN TYMON on Sunday 19th of January 2014 08:50:40 PM

__________________

http://www.flickr.com/photos/johntymon/
Tim Wilcox


Status: Offline
Posts: 1031
Date:
Permalink  

So it's all over and I got just over 50% as per usual but the Mystery Birds has been my favourite competition ever. Huge thanks to Ian for giving us all such a great challenge over the last few years. I'll miss it

__________________
dave broome


Status: Offline
Posts: 2872
Date:
Permalink  

Ian Campbell wrote:

Perhaps those of you that have never attempted it before could give this months a go and then join in next Year in order to encourage Ian that members of this forum appreciate his efforts.




Couldn't agree more, there's no shame in getting them wrong, they make you think and then kick youself when you see how you missed something obvious.......or is that just me confuse Giving them a go could fill a few minutes in the doldrums between Christmas and New Year, what are you waiting for?

__________________
Ian Campbell


Status: Offline
Posts: 2660
Date:
Permalink  

Just sent Ian my attempt(guess) at this Months Mystery Bird Competition, I get more wrong than right but the fun is in the doing and then finding out why I was wrong. Just like to thank Ian for the time he must put into running this competition, it's been going for 7 Years now and to ask that he continues to tease us into Year 8. Perhaps those of you that have never attempted it before could give this months a go and then join in next Year in order to encourage Ian that members of this forum appreciate his efforts.
Happy New Year to all.
Cheers Ian

__________________
Nick Isherwood


Status: Offline
Posts: 1189
Date:
Permalink  

Thanks Neil. That did the trick.

__________________
Some of my photos. www.flickr.com/photos/nickish77
Neil Calbrade


Status: Offline
Posts: 55
Date:
Permalink  

Try refreshing the page, that should kick it into life.

Neil

__________________
Nick Isherwood


Status: Offline
Posts: 1189
Date:
Permalink  

It's not showing on mine Ian. It's got Novembers birds down as October for some strange reason but the October results aren't shown.

__________________
Some of my photos. www.flickr.com/photos/nickish77
Ian McKerchar


Status: Offline
Posts: 15815
Date:
Permalink  

Been published since yesterday evening Nick and I know many others have already read it so it's definitely up there.

__________________

Forum administrator and owner
Nick Isherwood


Status: Offline
Posts: 1189
Date:
Permalink  

And still it goes on! The October reveal isn't on Ian.

__________________
Some of my photos. www.flickr.com/photos/nickish77
simon ghilks


Status: Offline
Posts: 560
Date:
Permalink  

Congratulations go to Mr Ian Mckerchar now the proud world record holder for the longest dramatic pause in history.
Dermot O'Leary, Tess Daly eat your hearts out.
The tension is unbearable.wink

__________________
Jon Bowen


Status: Offline
Posts: 455
Date:
Permalink  

Jon Bowen wrote:

Can't put it off any longer, beer in the fridge, P J Grant at my elbow for support - time to tackle those gulls !!

-- Edited by Jon Bowen on Sunday 24th of February 2013 07:10:00 PM





update - beer no longer it fridge bottles in bin with Mr Grant

__________________
Dennis atherton


Status: Offline
Posts: 819
Date:
Permalink  

they are all Bl@@dy all Herring Gulls,

This to me show how the camera lies, some of the birds seem to have a darker mantle, one seemed to have a shorter bill at the angle in the shot, well done to all that went for the right answer, the left of center seemed to have a bigger head, never trust the camera, i like to take photos but i found this shot a great example how the angle of the bird compared to the light can change the colour and show the same birds looking slightly different, that was a bad un,

or should i say it was seemingly a Bad un till i saw mystery bird 6, i still cant see the bird,

__________________
Did you see it? It was small and brown and flew that way.........................
Paul Hurst


Status: Offline
Posts: 102
Date:
Permalink  

Jon Bowen wrote:

Can't put it off any longer, beer in the fridge, P J Grant at my elbow for support - time to tackle those gulls !!

-- Edited by Jon Bowen on Sunday 24th of February 2013 07:10:00 PM




I've been looking at them blankly for the past week, trying to muster the courage to go through those juveniles! (I hate gulls!)

__________________
Target birds: Golden Plover, Little Owl, Common Crossbill.
Jon Bowen


Status: Offline
Posts: 455
Date:
Permalink  

Can't put it off any longer, beer in the fridge, P J Grant at my elbow for support - time to tackle those gulls !!

-- Edited by Jon Bowen on Sunday 24th of February 2013 07:10:00 PM

__________________
Craig Higson


Status: Offline
Posts: 1274
Date:
Permalink  

He's at it again. You'd think he'd be a bit generous seeing as its the festive season, but no! How about something easy like a Sykes warbler instead?

-- Edited by Craig Higson on Thursday 13th of December 2012 09:26:19 PM

__________________
No one on their death bed ever said they wished they'd spent more time at work. http://bitsnbirds.blogspot.co.uk
Dennis atherton


Status: Offline
Posts: 819
Date:
Permalink  

Joe Wynn wrote:

Are you allowed to call them all seagulls?






Yep, got it right Joe there all seagulls, that was my answer too

__________________
Did you see it? It was small and brown and flew that way.........................
Joe Wynn


Status: Offline
Posts: 410
Date:
Permalink  

Are you allowed to call them all seagulls?

__________________
A few of my photos : Joewynn's Flickr I've got a Blog!
Adam Jones


Status: Offline
Posts: 827
Date:
Permalink  

I hate gulls (or at least identifying them). This is going to be a very long month.
Thank you Ian. I would have stuggled with one, let alone the number in this pic. A good challenge though.

__________________
My blog: The Early Birder
Dennis atherton


Status: Offline
Posts: 819
Date:
Novembers Naughtyness
Permalink  

Bl**dy Hell,


Good luck you Gullers, Novembers gulls photo is a Stinker, Either that or im just rubbish at gulls, maybe a bit of both there, i dont think there will be an 88% next month


__________________
Did you see it? It was small and brown and flew that way.........................
Matt Potter


Status: Offline
Posts: 353
Date:
RE: McKerchars mystery birds
Permalink  

Ian Campbell wrote:

Just looked at the results for July, I don't mind admitting I was one of the "have not got a clue" for bird 14. Now it's revealed as a Great Skua I still don't get why it has blue in it's tail, none of my guide books show this. or is my monitor wrong?. Someone help me, please.
Cheers Ian




Thats the one I actually got right! The 'purple/blue sheen' tried to throw me, but I wne t with gut instinct on it!

I think its a bit og a light trick on the black / dark edge band to the secondaries or tertials?

I sound like I know what I am talking about there!!

__________________
Ian Campbell


Status: Offline
Posts: 2660
Date:
Permalink  

Just looked at the results for July, I don't mind admitting I was one of the "have not got a clue" for bird 14. Now it's revealed as a Great Skua I still don't get why it has blue in it's tail, none of my guide books show this. or is my monitor wrong?. Someone help me, please.
Cheers Ian

__________________
Geoff Hargreaves


Status: Offline
Posts: 1474
Date:
Permalink  

On the lighter side of this comp,I said it was a puffin, I new it was a puffin so why I went razorbill will always be a mystery, after all my grandad could have seen the 1932 bird and
both me and me dad could have seen the 1984 birdnice to know l I live in the best gm borough for puffin study opportunity

Lanner falcon3 bird books,1 cd all in the bin,I,ll just use the pin next month

happy reading,geoff



__________________

mm
Dean Macdonald


Status: Offline
Posts: 679
Date:
Permalink  


Not forgetting Black Guillemot of course

"... red legs and lacking huge white wing patches"

__________________
Mark Rigby


Status: Offline
Posts: 1850
Date:
Permalink  

Dean Macdonald wrote:


"You can see the red legs under the water, Puffins are the only auk with red legs"




Not forgetting Black Guillemot of course

__________________
Dean Macdonald


Status: Offline
Posts: 679
Date:
Permalink  


I must stop doing the mystery birds on a sat night after a few beers

A few weeks ago, on a trip to Bempton cliffs, i explained in great detail to my wife how to pick out the Puffins on the water. "You can see the red legs under the water, Puffins are the only auk with red legs" said I.

So why did i say Razorbill.

__________________
Matt Potter


Status: Offline
Posts: 353
Date:
Permalink  

Iain Johnson wrote:

I agree Dennis, we should all put it behind us.......





Bottom just getting started Iain......

__________________
Iain Johnson


Status: Offline
Posts: 383
Date:
Permalink  

I agree Dennis, we should all put it behind us.......

__________________
Dennis atherton


Status: Offline
Posts: 819
Date:
Permalink  

i think we are all a bit BUMMED out by this thread, time to move on me thinks smile.gif

__________________
Did you see it? It was small and brown and flew that way.........................
Mike Chorley


Status: Offline
Posts: 1614
Date:
Permalink  

Before it gets too farcial!biggrin.gif

__________________
Bus pass birdin' great innit?
Matt Potter


Status: Offline
Posts: 353
Date:
Permalink  

Dennis atherton wrote:

They just keep getting Better smile.gif





Its a rather CHEEKy thread!! It will RECTUrM to normal soon!!!

__________________
Dennis atherton


Status: Offline
Posts: 819
Date:
Permalink  

They just keep getting Better smile.gif

__________________
Did you see it? It was small and brown and flew that way.........................
Dean Macdonald


Status: Offline
Posts: 679
Date:
Permalink  


Or Fat Bottomed Girlsno.gif

__________________
Mike Chorley


Status: Offline
Posts: 1614
Date:
Permalink  

Gentlemen, I think your efforts should be celebrated in songsing.gif

Maybe the London DerryAire?

__________________
Bus pass birdin' great innit?
John Rayner


Status: Offline
Posts: 2673
Date:
Permalink  

Dennis atherton wrote:

Much better, biggrin.gif



I agree Dennis,

You've set the standards of these puns but Matt's last post nearly wrecked 'em.

However, he is trying hard so it's quite pleasing to see that you may not our sole wit on the forum.

Cheers, John


__________________
Dennis atherton


Status: Offline
Posts: 819
Date:
Permalink  

Much better, biggrin.gif


Matt Potter wrote:

Dennis atherton wrote:

Cmon Matt, bottom of the barrel with that joke, i expected more, no.gifsmile.gifbiggrin.gif





A midibum of decorbum is required here......

-- Edited by Matt Potter on Wednesday 6th of April 2011 08:56:10 AM



__________________
Did you see it? It was small and brown and flew that way.........................
Matt Potter


Status: Offline
Posts: 353
Date:
Permalink  

Dennis atherton wrote:

Cmon Matt, bottom of the barrel with that joke, i expected more, no.gifsmile.gifbiggrin.gif





A midibum of decorbum is required here......

-- Edited by Matt Potter on Wednesday 6th of April 2011 08:56:10 AM

__________________
Dennis atherton


Status: Offline
Posts: 819
Date:
Permalink  

Cmon Matt, bottom of the barrel with that joke, i expected more, no.gifsmile.gifbiggrin.gif

__________________
Did you see it? It was small and brown and flew that way.........................
Matt Potter


Status: Offline
Posts: 353
Date:
Permalink  

Dennis atherton wrote:

Not sure about the arse end of those geese but i did laugh at all the bum puns, bottoms up, round 4 biggrin.gifsmile.gif

I am going to get really anal with this one........

__________________
Dennis atherton


Status: Offline
Posts: 819
Date:
Permalink  

Not sure about the arse end of those geese but i did laugh at all the bum puns, bottoms up, round 4 biggrin.gifsmile.gif

__________________
Did you see it? It was small and brown and flew that way.........................
Dennis atherton


Status: Offline
Posts: 819
Date:
Permalink  

Well done Matt,
im glad you did not fall for the green post with seeds on it that looked just like a post at Penny flash, have you seen next months though? the bar just got raised biggrin.gifno.gif

Enjoy the homebrew smile.gif


Matt Potter wrote:

I got them both correct!!!!!!!!!! Whoo Hoooo!!!! biggrin.gif I am very pleased!!

I may even get one more pint of homebrew poured to celebrate!! biggrin.gif





__________________
Did you see it? It was small and brown and flew that way.........................
1 2 3  >  Last»  | Page of 3  sorted by
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.
BACK TO THE MANCHESTER BIRDING WEBSITE HOMEPAGE -> Manchester Birding Forum -> GENERAL BIRDING DISCUSSION -> McKerchars mystery birds

RODIS

 

This forum is dedicated to the memory of Eva Janice McKerchar.