MB

  All users of this forum, please ensure you familiarise yourselves with the sticky posts at the top of each forum; posts not conforming to these guidelines and requests will be deleted.

Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: THE GREATER MANCHESTER 200 CLUB.


Status: Offline
Posts: 1419
Date:
RE: THE GREATER MANCHESTER 200 CLUB.


Well what start to 2018, seems listing is still a special thing for some GM birders, I have been asked if we need to set up a top table or rename the club to The GM 250 clunb, its seems 200 is easy nowadays, hahaha, I doff my cap to all who have added to there list recently, remember its just for fun and the only way to add more is

Keep Birding.



__________________


Status: Offline
Posts: 1536
Date:

thank you very much fellow birders smile
keith, have sent you a pm.

__________________
saburke


Status: Offline
Posts: 1531
Date:

Congratulations Steve!

-- Edited by keith mills on Saturday 27th of January 2018 05:41:46 PM

__________________

Rumworth List 2018: Species to date 79 Latest: Sedge Warbler, Common Tern, Whitethroat, Swift, House Martin.



Status: Offline
Posts: 1419
Date:

Mr Burke what an excellent way to get your GM200 bird a double seen on Merseyside and GM borders, I wonder how many times the Hoodie has done this, I have done the same as well, seen it on both location, as it is a lovely bird, I have a soft spot of corvids.

So Welcome to the oddest club in the birding world, I hope you enjoy your birding from now and add the the most sort after list in GM.

Keep Birding



__________________


Status: Offline
Posts: 261
Date:

Nice one Steve....


__________________
Aint birdin brill......


Status: Offline
Posts: 1549
Date:

steven burke wrote:

Rob Creek wrote:

Well done Steve ... but ... didn't you have Hooded Crow (same one?) not so long ago near Haydock when the debate was on if it was in GM or not, when viewed from another road???
Surely not still on 199?
biggrin






how mean of you mr creek & here is me thinking you were a really nice man no
the hooded crow near haydock back in October when I watched it was clearly not in gm hence the reason I went to see the hooded crow(same one) in ashton -in-makerfield which clearly is in gm biggrin
cheers rob wink
thank you to all who have congratulated me.



Haha, I am a nice man smile
Seriously though Steve well done mate, I don't do listing but I know it takes some doing to get 200!



__________________


Status: Offline
Posts: 1536
Date:

Rob Creek wrote:

Well done Steve ... but ... didn't you have Hooded Crow (same one?) not so long ago near Haydock when the debate was on if it was in GM or not, when viewed from another road???
Surely not still on 199?
biggrin






how mean of you mr creek & here is me thinking you were a really nice man no
the hooded crow near haydock back in October when I watched it was clearly not in gm hence the reason I went to see the hooded crow(same one) in ashton -in-makerfield which clearly is in gm biggrin
cheers rob wink
thank you to all who have congratulated me.

__________________
saburke


Status: Offline
Posts: 1549
Date:

Well done Steve ... but ... didn't you have Hooded Crow (same one?) not so long ago near Haydock when the debate was on if it was in GM or not, when viewed from another road???
Surely not still on 199?
biggrin

__________________


Status: Offline
Posts: 979
Date:

Congratulations to Mr. Steve Burke who has just joined the club.

__________________


Status: Offline
Posts: 1419
Date:

Mr Hargreaves, yes I have found the papers and correspondence regarding the self found rules , and to simplify for the common everyday birds, ie Coot Mallard Pigeon etc its the largest count of that species thats you have seen that year. Now on the same shelf was the rules from the now defunct UK 250 Club , they had some great self found rules , the re-find rules is very strange , re-finding a bird rare or not , the rule again roughly is... the bird has to have been unreported from some time and believed to have moved on, ( the time is flexible ) then you have to be surprised by the re-find.. hahaha basically it all a load of ...... well whatever you want it to be, listing is listing its fun and challenge , and game one up-manship.

I have had some great twitches and kept great day list week list month lists year list holiday lists ect ect, and it was all good fun.

I now want to look back on those days with fond memories and move on to a different level, again just for the love of birding.

Have fun which ever way you want to bird, just Keep Birding.

ps a birder once told me his mate had a huge Garden list... he rules were he counted anyones garden, or any garden any bird was flying over



__________________


Status: Offline
Posts: 1466
Date:

Paul,deep in the library (if memory serves)there is an article by Ian which covers his "self found" definition,something along the line ofyou visit a patch a few times and note the Coot present. if on the next visit there is an increase you have selffound aCoot.That may be wrong but a list is just your own record,my puzzle is if you refind a bird or a rare bird turns up years later is it self found times2.

happy listing geoff



__________________
Parish Listing,dare you


Status: Offline
Posts: 560
Date:

Feliz Navidad from Madrid !

To all friends in the Manchester birding community, (whether in the 200 club or not); and if its not too soppy, a special Merry Christmas to all those Hawfinches this last few months who brought so much pleasure and fun to many of you; - (candidates for species of the year?)

I havent been in Manchester since last January so didnt have the pleasure myself of bumping into a Hawfinch down there.

Best Wishes for 2018!

Miguelito



__________________

Why not?



Status: Offline
Posts: 1419
Date:

May all GM Birders have a happy festive time and a bird-full start to the new year, lets hope 2018 can bring back some good old fashion GM twitches, all the best.

Keep Birding



__________________


Status: Offline
Posts: 1419
Date:

Sorry Gentlemen, for the late reply.

Mr Charles Owen, has a list of 200 ! just for Pennington, wow ..now that's a proper list, well done that man, these are the right and proper members of the GM200 Club.

The club was originally going to be called the silent meals club, due to the trouble we used to get in when we got home... however the GM200 Club, seemed to give, a target for people to try and reach, over the years I have often raced out just to add a bird to a list.

I know there has been loads of discussion on the rights and wrongs of listing, twitching etc but deep down it should always be personal, you can list what you want when you want, personally I have given up twitching ? ok Wallcreeper and Male Siberian Rubythroat maybe ones to pay homage to .

I do like the self found list which is open to all sorts of odd rules and anomalies, how do you self find a Coot or a Mallard ?

So the birders that have a list of 200 for one place are good old fashion proper birders, and I doff my cap to them, for I am well short of finding 200 birds in GM, and in fact recently as I have been on a Hawfinch hunt ( i know thats not PC ) but I mean a figurative hunt, I have seen loads of common birds really well, and it has brought back by real love for birding, which is just watching and seeing birds, really looking at them, watching behaviour, looking a plumage , and just watching birds.

Perhaps Club members should do that in 2018, lets have a return to old school birding, lets just enjoy birds for what they are, lists are fun and a little bit of competition is good. But enjoy your birding for whatever reason you want to.

Keep listing ,Keep Birding,



__________________


Status: Offline
Posts: 1466
Date:

As a long servingwaiter at the top table I,d hate to upset any new members with "sorry your not on the list" at this years xmasbash,please submit your list.

In good fun geoff



__________________
Parish Listing,dare you


Status: Offline
Posts: 1070
Date:

Another nominee from me - I like to keep things going! Charlie Owen has informed me that he too has over 200 birds on his Pennington List and would like to be considered for membership.

__________________
No one on their death bed ever said they wished they'd spent more time at work. http://bitsnbirds.blogspot.co.uk


Status: Offline
Posts: 560
Date:

A special Well done to Bill, an unassuming, modest and dedicated Pennington stalwart, with whom Ive had the pleasure to spend many a happy hour in recent years, (though not thus far in 2017).

Best Wishes, Bill,

Cheers,

Mike



__________________

Why not?



Status: Offline
Posts: 1070
Date:

I shall let him know Paul. I'll tell him to dust off his tux for the special medal presentation!

__________________
No one on their death bed ever said they wished they'd spent more time at work. http://bitsnbirds.blogspot.co.uk


Status: Offline
Posts: 1419
Date:

Craig I think a special medal for 200 birds at Pennington Flash is in order, puts a GM list in the shadows .

But hell yes Bill Harrison is a very welcome member of the GM 200 Club.



__________________


Status: Offline
Posts: 1070
Date:

Whilst chatting with Bill Harrison, Pennington Flash stalwart, the other day, he casually mentioned that the Arctic Skua the other day was his 200th species. Not in GM as he doesn't keep a GM list, just at Pennington. He's seen other birds in GM so his total must be well over 200 for the county. However I thought I'd submit his application for him just based on his Pennington total.

__________________
No one on their death bed ever said they wished they'd spent more time at work. http://bitsnbirds.blogspot.co.uk


Status: Offline
Posts: 560
Date:

Well done Mr. Tromans upon entering the hallowed portals of Mr. Heaton's Nuthouse. I do find the place to be a great source of comfort and solace in time of crisis/stress, with the added bonus of the availability of the padded rooms when things are very hard in the wider world beyond.

-A cautionary note though John, don't ever stay overnight, as the frequent wailings and gnashing of teeth from other inmates isn't conducive to a good night's sleep.

I did place a shilling each way on you to be the next new member, and shall be skipping to the local bookies to collect when it stops raining.

Regards,

Mike P.



-- Edited by Mike Passant on Thursday 29th of June 2017 07:07:51 AM

__________________

Why not?



Status: Offline
Posts: 1419
Date:

Rob, an extra 0, can just add a bit of fun, thought it best to edit it before the someone else does.

keep trying to reach new heights



__________________


Status: Offline
Posts: 1549
Date:

Paul Heaton wrote:

Mr John Tromans, how very pleasing that we can now add you as a full member of the elusive GM 2000 Club, well done on your latest two ticks, I hope you get many more.

Keep Birding.





You're damn right it's elusive Paul. It looks like John could well be up there on his own for many years to come. 2000 is some achievement and may never be rivalled in our lifetime. wink

__________________


Status: Offline
Posts: 1419
Date:

Mr John Tromans, how very pleasing that we can now add you as a full member of the elusive GM 200 Club, well done on your latest two ticks, I hope you get many more.

Keep Birding.



-- Edited by Paul Heaton on Wednesday 28th of June 2017 07:15:24 AM

__________________


Status: Offline
Posts: 560
Date:

The clubs ranks have swollen considerably since I last perused it in March of 2011 when there were some 20 members.

Presently in the published rankings are 29 people (comprising 2 ladies and 27 gentlemen). In addition are three other people whose names sadly no longer appear, (gone but definitely not forgotten), and an unknown number of "closet" members.

There have been no new entrants during the current year so far, so who might be the next one?

The smart money is on a certain Mr Tromans, a thoroughly nice man who enjoys his birding, but who has a masochistic streak in being a Birmingham City fan.

-Just teasing John!



__________________

Why not?



Status: Offline
Posts: 1419
Date:

Barry Hulme congratulations on reaching the grand total of 200 for your GM county list.
I had thought you were going to stay on 199 forever, well done,

An excellent bird the Sabines gull to gain you into the hallow halls of the GM 200 club.





__________________


Status: Offline
Posts: 1070
Date:

Indeed it was - on both counts! Apart from 1 or 2 obvious species I had pretty much used up my 'easy' ticks, so it was always going to have to be something a bit different, and a Hoopoe was just about as good as I could have asked for (apart from maybe a second Black-faced Bunting because I missed the first)!

__________________
No one on their death bed ever said they wished they'd spent more time at work. http://bitsnbirds.blogspot.co.uk


Status: Offline
Posts: 1419
Date:

Craig Higson, well done sir, what a cracking bird for your 200th. excellent way to become our newest member.

keep birding

__________________


Status: Offline
Posts: 1070
Date:

Well, assuming that the Hoopoe passes the County Rarities Committee I've added it to my list today which I reckon takes me to the magic 200 mark -as long is I don't discover any omissions and no one decides to lump meally redpoll with Arctic or other silly decisions of course.



-- Edited by Craig Higson on Sunday 26th of April 2015 05:40:25 PM

__________________
No one on their death bed ever said they wished they'd spent more time at work. http://bitsnbirds.blogspot.co.uk


Status: Offline
Posts: 1419
Date:

Vic Chatterton, thats excellent news , and having to use buses trains and walking makes it all the better.

and as for streetpeckers, hey we count them as well.

Congratulations on your efforts

__________________


Status: Offline
Posts: 1326
Date:

Is Vic there? He is now....well done Vic!smile

-- Edited by Ian Boote on Thursday 23rd of April 2015 08:21:40 AM

__________________


Status: Offline
Posts: 132
Date:

Saw a Barn Owl yesterday at a site in Gtr. Manchester - for obvious reasons can't say where. This and Sandwich Tern being the biggest GM blockers for me.

This brings my total to 200 in Gtr Manchester (201 really but I just can't count "Streetpeckers" (If I did then Two-barred Crossbill would have brought up the 200).
Living on the edge of Greater Manchester meant that I didn't keep a GM list but had a 10 mile list instead - otherwise I would have many more.
It was only when I checked up 2 or 3 years ago that I realised I was on over 190 that I started pursuing a list. Having to contend with bus, train and on foot meant that I've missed quite a few including the Heaton Park Red-rumped Swallows which I missed by 40 minutes.

__________________


Status: Offline
Posts: 560
Date:


Well done to Mr. Wilson on finally hitting the 200 mark in style, thanks to Simon's excellent double find at Heaton Park!

I wasn't in a position to make a move myself due to commitments in the NE, and even if I had set off, the birds would have been long gone before my arrival; - one of those situations where one takes life on the chin and quickly moves on.....

Best Wishes,
Mike P.

__________________

Why not?



Status: Offline
Posts: 1419
Date:

Mr Wilson, after very careful consideration, and a double recount of your list, its give us great pleasure to finally accept you as a member of the 200 club.

very good of Simon Johnson to share his excellent find with us all , allowing you to reach the magical 200 .

Perhaps you can repay him with a nice find at Elton.

Great to see so many faces again today.

keep birding your patch and sharing the news.

__________________


Status: Offline
Posts: 1070
Date:

Unfortunately I was on a train heading towards Leeds when the news broke! I didn't swear.

__________________
No one on their death bed ever said they wished they'd spent more time at work. http://bitsnbirds.blogspot.co.uk


Status: Offline
Posts: 641
Date:

Paul Heaton wrote:

Paul Wilson thats very upsetting news, to be one short, but your conduct as a gentleman, in informing us is very topper !

Now dont worry, its only the start of the year, and I am positive you will get that extra bird this year




Got it - Red-rumped Swallow - not a bad bird to bring up the 200

__________________

My bird photos collection on Flickr
latest update: December 2016



Status: Offline
Posts: 1419
Date:

Paul Wilson thats very upsetting news, to be one short, but your conduct as a gentleman, in informing us is very topper !

Now dont worry, its only the start of the year, and I am positive you will get that extra bird this year

Take care
Keep Birding.



__________________


Status: Offline
Posts: 641
Date:

Recently celebrated reaching the magical (?) 200 at a site recently (getting lots of congratulations from fellow birders). Unfortunately, something had gone amiss in my Excel spreadsheet where I keep my records, and for some reason Common Sandpiper appears twice!

Therefore, I'm still one short. :(

But, looking on the bright side, it shouldn't be too long (hopefully) before I can celebrate all over again :)

__________________

My bird photos collection on Flickr
latest update: December 2016



Status: Offline
Posts: 1419
Date:

Well what a Talk last night .Birders of Greater Manchester you missed a fine night of entertainment.

The Highlights were of course all the wonderful fact and figures In Mr Atkins presentation, and his new and first public story of the Willow Tit / Marsh Tit Saga, ,but i felt the Female Chairperson from the CHESHIRE wildlife group, thanking birders for making the journey from the North was just Hilarious, she was referring to the birders from Rochdale and the moors of Tameside .
it was a jest made in fun, but it did make us all laugh, and it was the best turn out at a meeting I had seen in ages.

I am concerned that the age range of these meeting is high, please if you have kids of your own or Grand kids get them into Birds flowers trees whatever, Birders and the like are now on the Red List .

Keep Birding.

up in the north you know who you are !

__________________


Status: Offline
Posts: 1419
Date:

It's a 7.30 start , sorry !

__________________


Status: Offline
Posts: 1324
Date:

Is it a 7.45 kick off?

__________________


Status: Offline
Posts: 1419
Date:

Well Gentleman and ladies a chance perhaps to put a face to a name

A Talk regarding the Breeding Birds of Greater Manchester by Steve Atkins.
For the Cheshire Wildlife Group.

Wednesday 26th November in the lounge of St Marys Church Moss Lane Sale M33 6GD.
3 non Members 2 members.

With perhaps, a tankard of ale! afterwards in the Plough Inn Aston Village.

Keep Birding.

__________________


Status: Offline
Posts: 1419
Date:

Well there we are the great and powerful webmaster has spoken, actually he a honourable member but keeps it quiet, .

As long as it is understood the Gm 200 is a pure fictitious part of mine and its members imagination, I am proud to be part of it, and see how Gm Birders race to the 200 mark, and enjoy a bit of banter along the way.

If anyone wants to put a face to a name Steve Atkins he presenting a talk at the Cheshire Wildlife trust on 26th November in St Marys Church Sale, can you imagine if the whole club turned up.

Be proud, Keep birding.

__________________


Status: Offline
Posts: 11517
Date:

There is only one person who can delete threads on this forum and I have no (nor ever have, despite being asked to do so previously) intention of doing so with this one...

__________________
Ian McKerchar (forum administrator and owner)


Status: Offline
Posts: 405
Date:

I'm on 130 and a target like 200 is a great motivator to bird in GM rather than always go to the low-hanging fruit nearer the coast or at RSPB places. The thread is brilliant to read too, and is a clear reason why the forum as a whole is one of the best birding sites on the web. The surreal touches about the Xmas do etc are the icing on the cake!

DO NOT DELETE IT!

__________________


Status: Offline
Posts: 1419
Date:

Sorry Craig, had not realised how close you were, dont worry safe for now, had a couple of positive feedbacks, thank you Gentlemen as we all know its is just that, a bit of fun, a benchmark for the heck of it, yet it makes Gm Birders want to go out and find stuff.

I certainly have spent more time birding in Manchester as a result of Ian's website and thank him for it, this thread has given me a great amount of enjoyment and I hope we can continue in the manner it was intended.

Craig,I wish you luck in getting in before the yuletide.

Bernard glad you have come out of the woodwork, and I wish you all the best in your next 9 visits

Keep adding to your GM List biggrin

__________________


Status: Offline
Posts: 1070
Date:

Noooooo you can't close it now. I'm only one away. I want to come to the Xmas party!


Personally I've found the 'club' a bit of inspiration. I'd never really considered my GM total before the GM webiste came along and the '200 club' was (for me) a tongue in cheek challenge almost. It's got me out in parts of GM I would never normally visit and I've discovered new sites as well as self finding some rather nice birds. Yes, it's always been a bit of fun, but I've enjoyed watching people move up to the magic number and its nice to be able to congratulate those that do make it. If the thread closed it wouldn't bother me particularly, but surely as long as everyone recognises that it is just a bit of fun......

-- Edited by Craig Higson on Tuesday 4th of November 2014 08:53:20 PM

__________________
No one on their death bed ever said they wished they'd spent more time at work. http://bitsnbirds.blogspot.co.uk


Status: Offline
Posts: 1419
Date:

Bernard Hooley, did we meet at the weekend at Binn Green

Sir I am happy you have considered signing up, however I must point out that the whole idea of the GM 200 Club started out as a practical joke between friends, and it has got out of hand, the Club is a imaginary one , a piece of my odd, off the wall sense of humour, I have asked Ian to perhaps close this thread, but as happened on Saturday, fellow birders, encourage me to continue, however please accept my apologies if anyone thinks its real, I am happy that people find it a challenge and a target to see 200 birds in GM, thats got to be good for the county.
I know of one birder taking it to the extreme and trying to see 100 species in each borough, now that a real challenge.

Please keep in touch private message me, as for everyone else, do we continue with the allusion or do we close the doors.

Stay real and as sane as you can, but

keep Birding.

__________________


Status: Offline
Posts: 147
Date:

Hi Paul I am one of the so called secret members of the 200 club.quite some time ago Keith mills advised me to. Join but I never quite got around to it.the rough legged buzzard was number191 in greater Manchester so I think it is time I signed up.

__________________
b. hooley


Status: Offline
Posts: 1419
Date:

A truly excellent day out today to Dovenstones /Binn Green, many thanks to Steve for alerting us to a wonderful bird, seeing a Rough legged Buzzard, against the craggy backdrops of the dark hills was just splendid. As was meeting Mr Passant in the field, or actually by the side of the road, So nice to finally put a face to the name. I met many other members adding to their list, and a few new members, methinks?

Plus the odd secret member adding the bird as well,

We do have a few secret members, shame really its a proud club.

Sorry the the birders I met today if I fail to mention your names, I am just rubbish with names, again thanks go to Ian McKerchar for putting the news out, and we hope the extra work updating all our list makes you smile.

Keep Birding.

__________________
1 2 38  >  Last»  | Page of 8  sorted by
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

RODIS

 

This forum is dedicated to the memory of Eva Janice McKerchar; rest in peace mum.